The WORST episodes of Judy Justice
Every episode of Judy Justice ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of Judy Justice!
The Honorable Judy Sheindlin, retired Judge of the Manhattan family Court, brings her signature blend of sharp wit and wisdom, hilarious candor and unwavering honesty that has made her America’s favorite judge for over 25 years, as she presides over real cases, arbitrates binding decisions and delivers what only she can: “Judy Justice.”
#1 - Family Road Rage Drama
Season 3 - Episode 36 - Aired 3/7/2024
A blended family sues their landlords after their lease is terminated, triggering a legal dispute involving allegations of harassment, false restraining orders, and property damage. A road rage incident ensues, with the former tenants claiming they were forced off the road and verbally attacked.
#2 - Holiday Dog Attack
Season 2 - Episode 30 - Aired 12/13/2022
A dog attack on Christmas day divides neighbors who fight over which of their dogs was the aggressor and who is responsible for vet bills.
#3 - Cat/Dog Fight Caught on Tape / Online Dating Gone Wrong
Season 1 - Episode 119 - Aired 4/14/2022
The Judge presides over two cases in this episode. In the first, a cat is mauled by a neighbor's leashed dogs after the cat allegedly startles the dogs while on a walk. In the next case, after meeting online, a man loans thousands of dollars to his new girlfriend. She claims he was moving too fast and all monies exchanged were gifts, not loans.
#4 - Dog-Watching Nightmare / Ex-Fiancée Fight
Season 1 - Episode 112 - Aired 4/6/2022
In the first case, a woman's two puppies are reported stolen while left in the care of a neighbor. In the second case, a man sues his ex-fiancé for the 10K court max over vehicle possession.
#5 - Restaurant Nightmare
Season 1 - Episode 110 - Aired 4/4/2022
A businessman takes a risk by opening a new eatery during the height of the pandemic; his venture ends with alleged theft and a contract dispute.
#6 - Family Woes
Season 2 - Episode 20 - Aired 11/29/2022
After providing a home for her grandchildren while her son was in prison, a woman's relationship with her family falls apart after he and his fiance move in.
#7 - High Security Break-Up
Season 2 - Episode 21 - Aired 11/30/2022
A woman is granted a lifetime restraining order against an ex-boyfriend who sues her for thousands in personal belongings he says she never returned.
#8 - Brawl for Dogs
Season 2 - Episode 19 - Aired 11/28/2022
Ex-roommates fight over a violent assault involving a lockout and an emotional support dog; one man claims he blacked out after a chokehold, another says it was self defense.
#9 - You Jumped On My Car! / Last Will and Testament Strife
Season 1 - Episode 109 - Aired 4/4/2022
In the first case, an army vet accuses a car buyer of jumping on her vehicle in an argument over the title. In the next proceeding, a married couple hire a woman to prepare their wills and end up being sued for 8K in damages.
#10 - Dude Where's My Truck? and Broken Bonds
Season 2 - Episode 101 - Aired 4/24/2023
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. In the first, a young man tries to do the right thing when he pays his great aunt $500 for an old truck she left on his property. She sues him for 5K after he disposes of the vehicle. Up next, a man is arrested when an argument with a friend escalates into a public altercation. ‘False' arrest claims are questioned when an active warrant comes to light.
#11 - Bullet-Riddled Betrayal
Season 3 - Episode 16 - Aired 2/8/2024
During an outing to purchase illegal drugs, a teenager driving his girlfriend’s car is caught in gun crossfire. To evade shots fired, he swerves and crashes the vehicle. His girlfriend reports the car as stolen and seeks $7K in damages to her now bullet-ridden ride.
#12 - Rag Doll Dog and Hairy Situation
Season 2 - Episode 27 - Aired 12/8/2022
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. Up first, two Pit Bulls jump over a fence and maul a neighbor's small dog; the Judge speaks to the responsibility that comes with owning dangerous dog breeds. In the next case, a woman sues a hairstylist claiming money owed for improperly installing a wig and destroying it.
#13 - Pay to Play and Contract Controversy
Season 2 - Episode 71 - Aired 3/13/2023
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first case, a hair-salon owner helps a friend pay for a luxury vehicle which he proceeds to crash; instead of paying her back, he then buys an expensive electric sports car. In the second case, A man accuses his ex-friend of repossessing his car without just cause and demands payback for the 5K he put into it.
#14 - Don't Go Fund Me
Season 2 - Episode 25 - Aired 12/6/2022
After an apartment fire made her homeless, a woman sues a former friend who offered her a place to stay, for a wrongful eviction and unwanted sexual advances while staying with him. He countersues for damages due to false accusations.
#15 - Tickets and Titles Between Friends / Star-Studded Keytar Crisis
Season 1 - Episode 118 - Aired 4/13/2022
The Judge presides over two cases in this episode. First, a man is sued by a friend for the alleged balance owed on a car; he is questioned about an 'evading the police' text that the Judge discovers. Next up, a software engineer sues a friend over design costs for an array of lights to enhance a keytar; the engineer is countersued for harassment.
#16 - Shared Driveway Destruction
Season 1 - Episode 111 - Aired 4/5/2022
A house flipper and his neighbor claim guns were allegedly drawn during a fight over repairs to their shared driveway.
#17 - Chihuahua Fright
Season 2 - Episode 43 - Aired 2/1/2023
A chihuahua is mauled by a larger dog; neighbors fight over liability and vet bills.
#18 - Beachside Community Fail
Season 2 - Episode 98 - Aired 4/19/2023
A man is sued for property damage to a $1400 a month pool house with no indoor plumbing. He claims his landlord assaulted him in a fight over unpaid utilities and disrespect.
#19 - Don't Bully Me
Season 2 - Episode 23 - Aired 12/2/2022
An American Bully breeder sues a man for the remaining balance on a puppy purchased for his seven-year-old daughter.
#20 - Three's a Crowd
Season 2 - Episode 26 - Aired 12/7/2022
After a fight with his pregnant girlfriend, a man invites a female acquaintance to move in; they clash over a personal loan, car damages and assault.
#21 - Business Review Bombshell
Season 2 - Episode 58 - Aired 2/22/2023
An electrical contractor sues for the 10K court maximum for negative online business reviews that he claims hurt his business; he is countersued for 10K for allegedly filing a frivoulous lawsuit.
#22 - From Puppy to Protective Order / Motorcycle Brothers' Payback
Season 1 - Episode 114 - Aired 4/8/2022
The Judge rules on two cases. First, a restraining order and vet bills come into play when custody of a Miniature Australian Shepard is disputed. Next up, brother sues brother over the remaining balance on a motorcycle.
#23 - Music Video Conflict and Family Overstays Welcome
Season 2 - Episode 44 - Aired 2/2/2023
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. First, a singer/songwriter sues the owner of a video production company for the money paid for music videos; the producer accuses him of violating their contract. In the next case, a woman sues her brother and sister-in-law for thousands in back rent and for damage to her property; they counter with claims of harassment and invasion of privacy.
#24 - Car Keying Caught on Tape
Season 2 - Episode 103 - Aired 4/26/2023
A not-so-neighborly dog walk results in vandalism and police intervention. A woman sues for a false arrest, lawyer fees and damages caused by the trauma of a night in jail.
#25 - Baby Horse Rejection and Bad Bug Paint Job
Season 2 - Episode 97 - Aired 4/18/2023
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first case, a woman makes a deposit on a foal six months before its birth but wants out of the contract once the animal is born. Believing the baby horse could not be insured, she sues for breach of contract. In the second case, a disabled veteran sues for a $6500 refund when the paint job on her beloved 1969 Volkswagen starts 'bubbling'.